June 12, 2011

Rules


Quite a few other bloggers have been posting about rules recently, most of them saying that they don't have lists of rules as slaves, that they're glad that they don't and that they regard such rules as petty and unrealistic and more associated with 'wanabee' fantasists than those truly living the lifestyle. i'm not sure if they really meant to say all that, but that's how i've interpreted what's been said. And the bit that's hit me hardest is the fact that the list of rules they're all being most critical about, the '128 basic slave rules' which can be widely found on the internet, is what my rules are based on. Sir read through that document, among others, took bits of it, adapted it and added to it and produced my first set of rules for when i was initially collared by Him (though i then had 70 rules, not 128). Since then my rules have been updated, due to our changing circumstances and as things happened which meant Sir needed to personalise them even further to our needs. But i can't get away from the fact that the type of rules i had, and still have, are precisely the type of rules which have come in for so much criticism of late on other blogs.

Before i go any further, i'm going to give you a link to the 128 Basic Slave Rules which i'm talking about: here and also to my rules (the first set i was given): here, so you can compare them. Yes there's differences and yes my rules are obviously personalised to me (and in my opinion some of the more silly or unrealistic rules have been omitted from the version my Sir devised, such as '#3. i worship my Master', '#61. my Master will decide what my sexual orientation shall be' or '#89. i will not wear a pad or tampon when i am on my period without His permission'.) But for some reason all this talk of unrealistic rules has left me feeling very vulnerable. i'm not questioning the solidity of mine and Sir's relationship, neither am i questioning the reality of our roles, i'm not even questioning how useful the rules have been for me or whether i really needed them, because i know that i did and i wouldn't have become the slave i am without them. Even today when it's not possible for me to follow all the rules i used to, due to commitments with the children, i still need to have a set of rules in order to feel like His slave and to know what is expected of me. Yes i have internalised His expectations by now, so i could survive without the physical written down rules, but if He took them away tomorrow i would still automatically abide by them because i know that's how He wishes me to behave.

i guess i'm just surprised that a fundamental element of our M/s relationship, one i rely on and need and value so much is so laughed at and frowned upon and derided by some others that up until now i have looked up to and respected. It doesn't give me a very good feeling inside to know this or to read the comments from others about how it's usually 'newbie', deluded, fantasist, game-playing, rose-tinted people who think these types of rules are a good idea and that once people enter into a proper real-life M/s relationship they soon realise that these types of rules are neither practical nor valuable. Especially now that i'm already feeling fragile and wondering what the future of our relationship will be due to the difficulties of looking after 3 young children, one of whom has complex special needs, i guess it doesn't do much to reassure me and it makes me question myself even more :(

That's it for now.

15 comments:

sl said...

Hi libby, sorry to read how you feel now. i think they are not you, you are the one to live with the lifestyle with ur Sir, so why care about what other comments? your rules are practical and valuable or not should only be judged by you and ur Sir.

i also plan to write the rules later because all i have are only written in my heart, i hope to make it explicit so as to remind my place as His slave.

Sending hugs and support to you :)

ps. i have shared a link of the older post about needs from your blog on my journal to my Master, hope you dun mind and so sorry to let you know until now cos i'm not sure where should i make a note to you.

4:28 PM
littlemonkey said...

Hey Libby,

You rules work for you and your Sir. That is the important thing. Sounds as if the people you are reading are busy defining the "one twue way". Is there one true way? NO. You know that you are not a wannabe fantasist (love that phrase,btw). Don't let someone else's words devalue what you have. You and your Master have created something for you both, cherish it.

and the kids thing? Having small ones is tough on any kind of relationship, vanilla or M/s. You just have to be mindful of it and work a little harder on staying connected as lovers and not become subsumed in the "mommy & daddy" roles. You can do it. ;D

5:37 PM
Dannah Bridger said...

Ugh. Face it, some people pop off at the mouth because there is little more than hot air between their ears.

It is ridiculous to say that only fantasists have rules. Employees have rules, citizens have rules...

Rules are necessary in all relationships. Some are written and formal (anyone ever heard of a marriage license?), others are quietly accepted (he washes the dog and takes out the trash). It would make absolutely NO SENSE to have a slave with NO RULES, when the rest of society has them.

IMNSHO, a slave WITHOUT rules is the one living in a fantasy and only play acting. Also, they are probably jealous that their Master didn't feel they were worth the time and effort to train.

Wow! It really burns me up that people are filling your head with such crap. Think logically and ignore them.

Hugs!
Dannah

6:24 PM
lunaKM said...

The longer I'm in my relationship the more rules I get. That's the way this relationship works for us. Sure, some reduce their rules to "obey" and that just means they do everything commanded, but they still have rules. They may not realize that the way the dress or how they've learned to serve their Dominant's dinner is essentially a rule.

Don't stress about the changes in your relationship; you'll adjust and grow closer together.

6:29 PM
sub-kitten said...

I'm very new to this blog so don't really know all the circumstances but as I read your post, I feel that you are both on firm and sure footing with your personalised rules. You both do and use what is best in your situation and are compromising as and when necessary - but the most important thing for me is that you as His feels secure and happy.

Thanks for the link to the 128 rules btw. I'm learning something new all the time!! All the best x

6:53 PM
L said...

I think people forget how important it is to have a base to start from. They can scoff at it all they want, but without that basic beginning, those quidelines and rules, how could they possibly have developed their slave nature and known how to serve? Even if they may not have a specific written down set of rules, their service is clearly rooted in the tradition of those and other slave rules.

9:20 PM
schiava said...

Libby, one of the dangers of blogging and getting caught up in the blogs of others is the judgements that happen along the way. Somehow, the vast majority of bloggers take the attitude that their way, their set of beliefs, are the "best" or the "only". Some bloggers read other blogs and use the "faults" of others to reinforce their own beliefs.

This tends to create a false image of what living in a D/s relationship is all about, imho. That is why I love your honesty, and I try to be equally honest, and represent our relationship as what it is - two people who are finding the best way to meet each other's needs and be as happy as possible within the relationship.

For us, it doesn't require a lot of formalized, written rules, but it *does* require a lot of intuitive reading of moods and learning what Padrone loves and wants from me. His expectations are more about my attitude than about my actions, for the most part, and that is one thing that i believe can't be forced upon a submissive.

We don't live together, like you and your Sir do, so it is a vastly different relationship in the way our roles are expressed. I may have tons more formal rules if we did, I don't know.

All I know is that you and He seem to have an incredibly loving, positive, fulfilling relationship. I hate that you feel so vulnerable because of the types of comments made regarding the rules, but you know as well as I do that some people simply mock to make themselves feel superior. It isn't necessarily directed towards anyone in particular, but rather a generic "slave" and "Master" who don't do things in the way they would design.

*sending a big hug for you and 4 extras for you to spread around as you see fit!*

~titty

1:28 AM
libby said...

thanks to everyone for your supportive comments. i know nobody has criticised me or my relationship directly, it just felt like their views were directed at me. i guess that's what happens when i'm feeling stressed and worn out and frustrated and anxious about the future.

So thank you for the reassurance, it's made me feel better and helped me remember just how strong and solid my Sir and i are, and part of the reason for that is the rules i have. Also i talked to flame about this in the chatroom last night and what she said made a lot of sense when i mulled it over in my mind.

Starting today in a more positive mood, and no poo smearing or excited "Glah"ing from the boys so far, so things are looking up already!

7:01 AM
Honey said...

Well. Here's the thing.

I read the list. I think it's pretty laughable to think this could be broadly applied. (Or, in totality, at all for any length of time) If asked to review it, I would totally mock it.

But I wouldn't mock you for having rules, or think less of you for them. If what you have works for you, great. We all mimic, and that your list came from there but was personalized to fit y'all- I have no issue with it. I just don't think it's a one-fits-all kind of deal.

But, you know, I've noticed that you tend to have a focus on understanding BDSM culture, and most of the time, I totally disagree with your conclusions because they don't fit with my experiences. I don't do the online thing, which you do. I don't even live in the same country as you do. We're completely different.

And, I totally honor and respect your experiences and opinions. I would encourage you to not let others who think differently cause you to doubt what you know to be right for yourself.

4:31 PM
Master Dream's precious treasure said...

libby~

i love this post! When Master and i first got together, i remember He and i going through the 128 rules as well and Him totally adapting them to our way of life and making them work for us. To this day i live by a much shorter more strict set of His rules that i wouldn't trade for the world.

i'm not saying that the rules Master has for me defines me, but i am saying that His rules keep me in line. They are simply a tool. Sure we could function without them but He chooses not to and this is our BDSM life.

That's what i love about this lifestyle. There are no set standards, if you're happy and healthy, truly, that is proof enough that rules are working for you!

Peace to you and yours!

9:52 AM
Sexperts said...

Libby, I personally do not have rules and I actually felt the opposite, that all the other bloggers have these lovely lists of long, detailed rules and they have more "real" M/s and D/s relationships than I do.

I guess the moral is, there are all kinds of bloggers out there and none of them is 100% right. :)

I think the fact that you have rules is great; I know many couples with rules and rituals and in no way do I think it is only the newbies or the wanna-bes! I think rules and rituals are a very real part of M/s for many lifestyle couples and I hope you won't let anyone else tell you how YOUR brand of M/s should look.

*hugs*

7:58 PM
babygirl cricket said...

Hello Libby, I am sorry it has been so long since I have been to your blog! A lot of changes have happened since I moved from blogspot onto my own domain, and I am finally getting around to catching up with the blogs I have enjoyed. Also, I am relinking you in my blogroll.

Anyway! I very much agree with the above comments here. I know for myself, I would be lost without the rules that my Master/Daddy has me follow. They are even being added to and changed in some areas as we speak, for I recently became Daddy's slave, as well as His baby girl. Rules to me, are the structure I need, I do so much better with them.

Respectfully,
baby girl tabby (aka cricket)
www.thesafeplayground.com

12:31 AM
libby said...

thanks to everyone who got involved in this interesting discussion, and hi again tabby! i found it particularly interesting to read that Sexperts felt less 'real' because she doesn't have the lists of rules that some other bloggers seem to! i guess it's reminded me once again that there really is no one 'right' way in BDSM and that variety is what makes the lifestyle so vibrant and healthy.

Thanks everyone.

8:47 AM
Mistress160 said...

libby, I'm like luna ... sol and I add more rules as we go on, so never feel alone in this. As you say we are all different ... and that difference is what makes the Lifestyle vibrant :)

6:16 AM
His Bebe said...

I can imagine how that would make you feel. For myself I can honestly say that the rules I have for my slave have been a Godsend! He's found himself more secure and confident in his ENTIRE life (work, home, social etc) because he knows without a doubt what makes me happy-which is all he ever wanted to do in the first place (we were best friends for 17 years prior to D/s relationship). So-I say don't stress yourself over people who can't comprehend how clearly rules can convey the little details so many vanilla relationships can't with "normal communication"! (I love reading your blog)!

11:46 PM